The Technological Turn
For much of history, philosophy treated “technology” (or techne) as a neutral tool—a mere means to an end. However, in the 20th and 21st centuries, philosophers have argued that technology is not just what we use, but the environment in which we live, fundamentally shaping our thoughts, relationships, and understanding of being.
Martin Heidegger: The Question Concerning Technology
In his seminal 1954 essay, Martin Heidegger argued that the essence of technology is not something technological (i.e., it’s not the machines). Instead, technology is a “way of revealing” the world.
Enframing (Gestell)
Heidegger used the term Enframing to describe the modern technological mindset. Under Enframing, nature is seen as a “standing reserve” (Bestand)—something to be ordered, calculated, and used for human purposes. A river is no longer a river, but a source of hydroelectric power. Heidegger warned that this mindset risks stripping the world of its mystery and turning humans themselves into just another resource to be optimized.
Technological Determinism vs. Social Constructivism
A central debate in the field is over the “autonomy” of technology:
- Technological Determinism: The view that technology follows its own internal logic and “propels” society in certain directions. Once the internet or the steam engine is invented, specific social and economic changes become inevitable. (e.g., Jacques Ellul).
- Social Constructivism (SCOT): The view that human choices, social values, and political power determine which technologies are developed and how they are used. Technology is a product of culture, not its master.
The Ethics of Emerging Technologies
As technology advances, it creates “ethical lag”—situations where our tech capabilities outpace our moral frameworks. Key areas of concern include:
1. Artificial Intelligence and Algorithmic Bias
What are the moral status and rights of sentient AI? How do we ensure that algorithms (for hiring, policing, or loans) do not entrench existing social prejudices? The “Black Box” problem refers to the difficulty of understanding how complex AI systems reach their decisions.
2. Transhumanism and Human Enhancement
Philosophers like Nick Bostrom explore the possibility of using technology to overcome human biological limitations (aging, disease, cognitive limits). Is this the next step in human evolution, or does it risk creating a “post-human” class and deepening social inequality?
3. Surveillance and Privacy
In the age of “Surveillance Capitalism” (Shoshana Zuboff), our digital lives are constantly monitored and monetized. This raises questions about the erosion of the “private self” and the potential for technological social control.
Technology and Human Relations
How does the mediation of our lives through digital screens affect our ability to connect?
- Albert Borgmann distinguished between “Focal Practices” (like cooking a meal or playing an instrument together) and “Device Paradigm” (where devices provide a commodity with no effort, potentially leading to social alienation).
- Sherry Turkle explores how we are “Alone Together”—connected to dozens of people online but feeling increasingly isolated in our physical lives.
The Philosophy of Information (PI)
Luciano Floridi and others have proposed a new branch of philosophy that treats Information as a fundamental ontological entity. In this view, we are inhabitant of the “Infosphere,” and our moral duties extend to the integrity of information itself.
Environmental Philosophy and Technology
The “Anthropocene” is the era where human technology has become the dominant geological force. Philosophy of technology here intersects with environmental ethics: Can technology solve the climate crisis (e.g., through geoengineering), or is the very mindset of technological mastery the root cause of the problem?
Conclusion
Philosophy of technology is no longer a niche subfield; it is central to our survival and flourishing in the 21st century. As we move closer to the “Singularity” or face global ecological collapse, the ancient question “What is the good life?” must be answered in dialogue with the machines and systems we have created.
Recommended Further Reading
- The Question Concerning Technology by Martin Heidegger
- The Technological Society by Jacques Ellul
- The Age of Surveillance Capitalism by Shoshana Zuboff
- Superintelligence by Nick Bostrom